Of course there's the obvious reaction from any sane person - that these people claim to be Christians, but that Jesus, even the non-religious historical Jesus, was a celebrator of life, and by all accounts saddened by any unnecessary or untimely death. And let's put aside the way that these people are preying on their undeserving victims in what has to be the darkest days of their lives.
For now, let's focus on the legal case.
Here's a bit of a taste of what the sentiment was in the courtroom today and what the justices are wrestling with. I'll get to my ideas for a solution on the other side:
The difficulty of the constitutional issue was palpable in the courtroom as the justices weighed the case of Albert Snyder. His son died in Iraq in 2006, and members of a family-dominated church in Topeka, Kan., protested at the funeral to express their view that U.S. deaths in Afghanistan and Iraq are God's punishment for American immorality and tolerance of homosexuality and abortion.
Margie Phelps, arguing the case for her family's Westboro Baptist Church, said the message of the protests at military funerals and elsewhere is, "Nation, hear this little church. If you want them to stop dying, stop sinning."
via news.yahoo.com
Of course I'm not a lawyer, but these very well-qualified lawyers seem to have some issues with this, so I'll add my .02 - Let's see proof!
How about if the Westboro Baptist Church is guilty and has to accept the lower court's verdicts, unless they can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that god hates America and the killing would stop if we stop sinning. Perhaps, for example, there was a time or place in history when people were without sin or nobody innocent died? If so, let's see the verifiable facts, and Westboro is off the hook.
Otherwise, if these people are spreading hateful speech (and lower courts have already decided they are) and harming the families of recently deceased veterans with allegations that they can not prove, then I don't think that free speech should be a viable defense. Freedom, with responsibility is the way I like my America....
